Sunday, August 20, 2017

Rendez-Vous of Deja Vu

Year: 2013
Genre: Comedy
Directed: Antonin Peretjatko
Stars: Vimala Pons, Gregoire Tachnakian, Vincent Macaigne, Marie-Lorna Vaconsin, Thomas Schmitt, Esteban, Philippe Gouin, Lucie Borleteau, Pierre Merejkowsky
Production: Ecce Films

A museum guard (Tachnakian) and a flabby physician (Macigne) convince their two young paramours to take a road trip with them to the beach. That is the basic setup for Rendez-Vous of Déjà vu (the French title loosely translates to The Girls of Bastille Day), an absurdist comedy which gently ribs contemporary French culture while lifting enough anachronisms from the Nouvelle Vogue to make Francois Truffaut smile with mischievous glee. Its National Lampoon’s Vacation (1983) meets Band of Outsiders (1964), National Lampoon’s Going the Distance (2004) meets Pierrot le Fou (1965), National Lampoon’s Dorm Daze (2003) meets Weekend (1967)…Basically National Lampoon’s European Vacation (1985) done right.
 
Ugh, this movie...
In case it wasn’t entirely obvious, my ability to truly enjoy the playful subversions of the French New Wave is directly proportional to my ability to enjoy National Lampoon movies. This is to say I like the early stuff, but as the parade wore on, it felt less like entertainment with cohesion or meaning and more like a smug, self-satisfied auto-felatio. Yes, I know Godard, Truffaut, Resnais et al. are unassailable film Gods, but just like when I get giddy about Guy Maddin movies in front of certain friends, you either get French New Wave or you don’t.
 
Sadly, I don't.
I am however objective enough to appreciate its meaning and contribution. This is part of the reason why I like Rendez-Vous of Déjà vu. It generously borrows from the same pool of subversion – disengaged youth in revolt narratives, elliptical editing, fourth-wall breaks, political and philosophical ponderings. Yet it never takes itself too seriously. It doesn’t fold under the lofty ambitions of the film movement its paying homage to. Nor is its insertion of Bunuelian absurdity confusing bewilderment for bemusement.

Much like the works of Edgar Wright, director Antonin Peretjatko is playing with genre conventions to give us something that is halfway between homage and sly mockery. And he’s doing so with the same youthful regard that first put the Nouvelle Vogue on the map in the first place. All throughout the film, there’s a permeating sense of reckless abandon; a joy in slamming plates of spaghetti against the wall to see what sticks. Garish displays of violent middle class morality thrashing against a cerebral yet silly tone. There are random narrative avenues that just seem to die before miraculously living once more; complex comedic setups that coexist along startling non-sequitors. It’s creativity nearly at its most primal.

If Rendez-Vous of Déjà vu has an Achilles Heel it’s the fact that prior knowledge of 1960’s art cinema is pretty much a pre-requisite. I suppose it’s possible for someone to see this film and work their way backwards. But if that’s your strategy then the early works of Leos Carax might actually do more to prepare you for the delirious heights of the French New Wave (not to mention its pretentiousness).

Yet if you do indeed know who shot the Piano Player (1960),  are have at least been exposed to the world’s most bizarre lateral shot, then Rendez-Vous of Déjà vu may just be the movie for you. It’s a fun little romp into lunacy brought together by artists who seem to have a real love for what they’re lampooning.

Final Grade: B-

Saturday, August 19, 2017

Our Song



Year: 2000
Genre: Drama
Directed: Jim McKay
Stars: Melissa Martinez, Anna Simpson, Kerry Washington, Marlene Forte, Raymond Anthony Thomas, Rosalyn Coleman, Carmen Lopez, Tyrone Brown, Lorraine Berry, Natasha Frith, Chuck Cooper
Production: IFC

Our Song is by today’s standards a precious little indie movie. It’s clumsy, somewhat cheap-looking, strives for the cinema verite blend of social awareness but can’t help but betray its own sense of realism with predictable Hollywood story-beats. Yet when Our Song came out in the year 2000, it must have been something of revelation. Lest we forget that when filmmakers dared to focus on the urban POC experience in earnest, the films largely aimed the lens at masculine subject matter. Boyz ‘N the Hood (1991), Menace II Society (1993), Gridlock’d (1997), by comparison the only thing young black women had to latch onto was A Different World (1987-1993).

Well, that and Sister, Sister (1994-1999)
Enter music video director Jim McKay, whose one-two punch of Girls Town (1996) and Our Song explored the complex and grounded worlds of young black women, as they formed friendships, experimented with boys, confronted forms of oppression and otherwise forged their own identities, under the backdrop of urban decay. At least those films did so as well as a white director could explore those themes without coming across as flaccid or worse out of touch and paternalistic.

Like some movies...

Our Song is the better of the two. In it, three Brooklyn teens, all members of the elite Jackie Robinson Steppers Marching Band, try to hang onto each other as pillars of support before their school closes for asbestos removal. Lanisha (Washington) the one with the most stable family life, i.e. divorced parents on relatively good terms, realizes early on that the other two are taking divergent paths. Joycelyn (Simpson), takes a job at a local boutique and befriends the older girls working there, while Maria (Martinez) battles with the complex emotions that come with an unexpected pregnancy.

It’s easy to see how this kind of mix of after-school-special clichés could have gotten Novel by Sapphire (2009) real quick. Yet little in the film really transpires like you think it will. It’s a true example of characters balancing their resolve and opportunities (or lack thereof), hiding their vulnerabilities, leaning on each other while realizing they all will just have to depend less and less on each other over time. It’s just a part of growing up.

Our Song focuses almost exclusively on the aspect of growing pains and as a result the audience is compelled by the meta-narrative to think about times people in your life drifted away. I myself can recall several occasions over the course of my life when the one thing that formed close bonds suddenly ceased to be a la high school, soccer, a move to a different town.

A little confrontation goes a long way...
Yet one can’t help but wish the film didn’t trim so much fat from the process. Many of the subplots build towards some kind of confrontation. Much ado is made about Maria’s secrecy towards her mother (Lopez), a point that is juxtaposed by Lanisha’s relationship with her own parents. Yet nothing ever really comes of this other than Maria shrugging off her mom’s realization that the school is closing. Likewise Joycelyn’s departure from the group is given the promise of a confrontation but it never arrives.

Of course these concerns are beside the point given that the film is about drifting apart, not clashing together. While it’d be nice to get a sense of closure from a movie that wouldn’t be hurt by it, the truth of the matter is Our Song is true to form. Much like friendships formed in high school, the film ends and you’re not exactly sure how or why but there’s definitely a lump in your throat.

Our Song is maybe a little dated and may be a bit too concerned with its dressed-down style. Yet its message and its personality shine through. Its earnestness is almost certainly a virtue, especially considering it explores the foibles of a population that rarely gets attention in cinema. Our Song may not be my favorite coming-of-age film but it’s certainly someone’s.

Final Grade: B-

Wednesday, August 16, 2017

Homo Sapiens



Year: 2016
Genre: Documentary
Directed: Nikolaus Geyrhalter
Stars: Nikolaus Geyrhalter
Production: Nikolaus Geyrhalter Filmproduktion

Homo Sapiens follows in the footsteps of Koyaanisqatsi (1982) and more recently Samsara (2011) in the way of wordless, structure-less documentaries that evoke feeling through montage. Yet the mode in which Homo Sapiens assembles itself is about where the similarities end. Samsara went through great pains to capture some of the most beautiful images ever while Homo Sapiens is very much concerned with tableaus of decay and putridity.

The images are eerily, hauntingly, strikingly beautiful. Not a single human is in frame; remnants of civilization are ever present but always in the process of being reclaimed by the earth. There are fast food restaurants fallen in disrepair, abandoned office buildings, leaky subways stations and cracked concrete as far as the eye can see. The images recall the staid, defiant sculpture works of Nancy Holt and Robert Smithson in the way they are presented.

Homo Sapiens however detracts from its themes and crosses a line of good taste when it captures static frames of Fukushima amid a jumble of other images. The finiteness and fragility of human life does feel more visceral when these images come about but they feel a lot less real as well. To put it in certain terms, it feels like watching a superhero movie whereby the villain wins. The world changes thanks to a sudden and irreparable change masterminded by a singular entity. Whether purposeful or not, Homo Sapiens seems to want to put its post-apocalyptic chips on nuclear fallout.

We as a species now know better. Human civilization is likely not going to be wiped out swiftly by our own hand but in a worst case scenario, peter out in a cloud of good intentions. Not one big mistake but a thousand tiny mistakes made by a collective unconscious that lives for today; tomorrow be damned.

Homo Sapiens not a pleasant film to watch. The sound design doesn’t even offer a modernist score a la Phillip Glass but rather bombards us with birds chirping, flies buzzing and wind bellowing against ceiling tiles and paper. And this is despite barely seeing anything but broken glass to justify such loud noise.

Ultimately Homo Sapiens is an art installation masquerading as a full-feature film. A moving photo album that, granted captures some interesting images but in its silence all but announces its themes. It then uses a terrible recent tragedy to mix the proverbial pot. A gambit that most may find fitting but to me, it feels like they’re crossing a line.

Final Grade: D.

Tuesday, August 15, 2017

Scarred Hearts



Year: 2016
Genre: Drama
Directed: Radu Jude
Stars: Lucian Teodor Rus, Ivana Mladenovic, Gabriel Spahiu, Marius Damian, Andrei Rus, Ilinca Harnut, Gheorghe Lazar, Sarra Tsorakidis, Bogdan Cotlet, Cosmin Sofron
Production: Komplizen Film

Scarred Hearts is based on a novel of the same name written by acclaimed Romanian writer Max Blecher. The book and film are largely biographical; between 1935 and his tragically death in 1938 at the age of 28 Blecher spent his days in and out of several hospitals due to spinal tuberculosis. Despite this, Emanuel (Rus), Blecher’s analog, is determined to live his life to the fullest, escaping into books, periodicals and bawdy conversations between the patients and nurses that occupy his sea side hospital. While all this is going on Emanuel falls for the enigmatic Solange (Mladenovic), whose becomes a fixture at the hospital, despite not being a nurse or patient.

Daniel Day-Lewis in My Left Foot (1989)
This is the basic premise of the story, and anyone going in with little knowledge of Romanian New Wave cinema may walk in assuming Scarred Hearts is going to be a My Left Foot (1989) type cinematic exercise. The kind of exercise that nowadays feels like a vanity project for Oscar hopefuls crossing their fingers and hoping this might be their year.

Yet Scarred Hearts isn’t really that kind of movie. The story is almost entirely from the perspective of Emanuel but so much of the film is shot with an almost clinical distance. Only twice are we given a close-up of our protagonist’s face and both times they are in times of emotional or physical distress. Otherwise the camera sets itself in the corner of a room and waits for the denizens of the hospital to populate the screen and walk across our stagnant panorama.

It’s an interesting choice, and it doesn’t really work given most of the characters are bedridden or somewhere close to it. There are times when placement of the camera almost feels uncomfortably voyeuristic. What this kind of distance does do is it allows the ensemble to truly interact with each other in meaningful ways. Emanuel goes through his own existential crisis but if you’re not really into where the script is taking you, there are many smaller stories hidden within the frames besides one’s struggle for meaning.

Nothing's more Altman-esque than photos in sepia!
It’s Altman-esque only with an unmistakably Eastern European flavor. As the film and its characters fill their respective groves, politics is then suddenly inserted into the text just to see what happens (this is the 1930’s after all). Suddenly the people you have been following around and caring about prove at the very least naïve at the prospect of world war. Emanuel seems especially naïve, being unable to feel the subtle shift in the room once he’s outted as a Jewish Romanian. It’s noteworthy to mention that Blecher never saw the full brutality of Nazism in his lifetime. Likewise the film never treads that path - nor should it, given the insular nature of the hospital.

It’s that insularity that ultimately allows Emanuel and Solange’s relationship to take shape. Shot with surprising color and vibrancy, Scarred Hearts provides a unique perspective of permanent hospitalization and terminal illness. One in which the pain and suffering ascribed to the situation coexists with the beauty of the human spirit.

Final Grade: C

Friday, August 11, 2017

The State of the Blog

Good news everyone! After months of threatening friends and family with taking my uniquely critical, curmudgeon-y voice to a new level, I have finally launched a professional website from which to spew my bile. Keeping with my theme, the website is:


In all seriousness though, I am very thankful to all those who have supported me the last few years. Those who have been with me since the beginning have seen this blog turn from a loosely personal journey towards a 4,000 movie watching goal to a movie themed weight-loss challenge that fizzled out like a wet M-80.
For the record, it didn't work.


That said, this blog isn't going away. Rather it's changing once more to a something a little more personal and a little less defined. Regular Reviews, Listicles, and The Essentials will be written and published via the new website. Non-current reviews and subjective rattlings will find a home here, where hopefully my unpopular opinions and controversial views won't ever be used against me.

Next steps - you ask? I don't know how about actually publishing from a nationally recognized newspaper or magazine? Maybe start a Youtube channel with a Patreon account. It's not like that's ever been done before. Worst case scenario I could always turn my Last Unicorn/Hobo with a Shotgun-mashup into a picture book!
Weirder things have happened is all I'm saying.


Friday, August 4, 2017

A Ghost Story

Year: 2017
Genre: Drama
Directed: David Lowery
Stars: Casey Affleck, Rooney Mara, Liz Franke, Barlow Jacobs, Kenneisha Thompson, Kesha, Sonia Acevedo, Carlos Bermudez, Yasmina Gutierrez, Will Oldham, Brea Grant, Rob Zabrecky
Production: A24

A Ghost Story is a movie of questions more than it is a movie about answers. Personal questions like, how do we know when to let go of our grief? Cosmological questions like, where do we go after die? Storied questions like, does the universality of the film's message justify its slump into generics? and practical questions like, why are we staring at a seven minute uninterrupted shot of Rooney Mara eating a whole f***ing pie on the kitchen floor?
At least we weren't present for the cooking process...
I put it rather glibly and part of me wants to dismiss this movie whole cloth. It channels the meditative pacing of a Tarkovsky film but lacks the visual acuity. It blends popular motifs from high-concept sci-fi but lacks much of the showiness. It grasps for drama but feels muted under the limitations it sets for itself. Truly if you come in with the expectation that you'll see a decent "flick," you may wind up disappointing yourself.

There is however, another way to see A Ghost Story. For beyond its questions, there's a deep well of feeling feeding into its Polaroid-esque frames. Perhaps not feelings that you actively seek to experience (mourning, melancholy, apathy and fear), but they exist so authentically in this film that they slowly sink into the soul. It's story, its characters, its technique - this film wounds you to your core. Trailblazing filmmaker Maya Deren once explained she wanted to make movies that "put on film the feeling which a human being experiences about an incident, rather than to record the incident accurately." It seems director David Lowery had the same idea.

To summarize A Ghost Story would, A: fail to capture its essence, and B: almost be beside the point. The best primer for a movie of this stripe is to meditate on a deeply emotional childhood memory or the memory of a lost loved one. For then you can put yourself in the shoes of our central couple (Mara and Affleck), one of which spends most of the movie as a mute ghost covered in a sheet with eye holes. It's an odd costuming choice to be sure, but one that works both as a simple metaphor and a call-back to times of childhood whimsy.

This in conjunction with the film's audacious editing gets us to understand that the titled ghost (and the film for that matter) perceives time differently. The film jumps and skips but never focuses on raising events but rather the imprint that is left behind. Dream logic prevails, but never to confuse or subvert. It rather gives a strange kind of comfort to the fears that lay dormant in the mind; that of the unknown unknown.

(Shutter)
A Ghost Story is a singular experience. The one shortcoming I winced at, may well be your favorite moment (or maybe the only good moment) in a movie that is as audacious as it is unassuming. I'm not going to claim I fully understand it. But I cannot deny that the feeling of it is constant and arguably eternal.

Final Grade: B-